(This week’s civic education and engagement column from Danville’s The Republican newspaper.)
Not long ago, the mayor of Hammond issued an order that two long-empty high schools be demolished so the property can be used for something else. Back in the 1970s, Hammond had five bustling public high schools. Now only two remain open. When the city’s industrial jobs evaporated, families moved to places with more promise.
Public reaction to the mayor’s decision has been predictably negative. Many people have a strong emotional attachment to the schools they attended. Those buildings often served as anchors for the community – in Hammond’s case, the older school welcomed its first students in 1932 – with generation after generation of local teenagers following. So it’s no wonder folks are angry and hurt that the mayor could be so cold and unfeeling as to wipe out a structure they believe to be “historic.” After all, it was a big part of their personal history.
The same thing happens when older homes, businesses, or features of parks are slated for replacement by something more contemporary. Social media explodes with accusations that county and town leaders have no respect or affection for the history of the places they serve – even when a private property owner is behind the project, not local government. “They want to destroy a historic structure!” comments fill the chatter sites.
But here’s what many of those people don’t understand: “old” does not automatically mean “historic.” Sure, when you were a kid you thought it was a cool house and the nice old lady who lived there baked cookies for you every time you mowed her lawn. Some of your favorite childhood memories involve the penny candy section of that dime store. You stood and stared for hours through that hobby shop’s windows, wishing you could buy that train set. That root beer stand made the best floats! Just because they were around in your childhood doesn’t make them (or you, for that matter) historic.
Historical significance comes from something more than age or nostalgia. A building may have special architectural or cultural value, or an important connection to a community’s history. The old house where you mowed the lawn may be one of dozens of ordinary, nearly identical homes. But what if it’s your community’s last surviving example of a home ordered from the Sears Roebuck catalog? That has some historic value. What if it served as the community’s first library? Ditto. The original owner became governor? Yep, that’s historic.
But if it’s simply an ordinary old structure with no particular historical significance, its age alone doesn’t make it historic. The same applies to public buildings like schools. People may have treasured memories connected to them without the buildings themselves being historically significant.
I have great respect for Indiana’s preservation community and the work they put into saving noteworthy structures and community features. But they have neither the resources nor the justification to save every old building, so they focus on the ones that matter most. Even when a building has genuine historical significance, that doesn’t automatically mean preserving it is the best use of limited public or private resources.
In my school board days, one of our priorities was continually investing in our schools to lengthen their service lives and keep up with students’ changing needs. Most people walking into Central Elementary would never guess that some of its structural components date back to the 1880s.
But as I frequently reminded my colleagues when we invested in those improvements, some school board somewhere down the road is going to have to decide that keeping Central open is no longer the most prudent use of taxpayer dollars. No matter how sound their reasoning or how carefully considered their plans, there’s one thing they’ll be able to count on: public reaction will be predictably negative.
